If you’re a homeowner trying to understand cedar roof cost in Lancaster PA, you’re likely sorting through a lot of questions right now. Maybe you’re wondering if cedar shake roofing in Lancaster is really worth the price. You might be looking at your aging asphalt roof and asking, “Is it time for something better?” Or maybe you’re drawn to the classic, warm look of cedar and want to know how it performs in our local climate—and what it’s really going to cost.
At JMK Roofing, we’ve worked with homeowners across the region who are curious about cedar, but hesitant due to cost or upkeep concerns. In this guide, we’re breaking it all down for you: the benefits, the price, the process, and what you can expect when you invest in a cedar roof.
Why Consider Cedar Roofing in the First Place?
A new roof is a big decision, especially if you’re considering something as distinct and premium as cedar. So let’s talk about why people choose it in the first place—and whether it’s the right fit for your home.
Natural Beauty and Character
Cedar shake roofing adds timeless curb appeal. It’s hard to beat the organic texture and rich tones of natural wood. As cedar weathers, it takes on a silvery-grey tone that many homeowners love, blending naturally into Lancaster’s traditional architecture and wooded landscapes.
Strong Performance with the Right Installation
When installed properly, cedar is more than just good-looking—it’s tough. Cedar has natural oils that help resist insects and decay. It also offers natural insulation, which can help regulate indoor temperatures and improve energy efficiency.
That said, cedar isn’t a “set it and forget it” option. Maintenance matters, especially in a climate like ours where moisture, snow, and ice are part of the seasonal mix. We’ll get into care tips in just a bit.
How Much Does a Cedar Roof Cost?
Now, let’s get to the heart of the matter—how much does a cedar roof cost? You may have seen a wide range of numbers online, and for good reason. Cedar roofing isn’t a one-size-fits-all purchase. Material quality, roof size, slope, accessibility, and the installer’s skill all factor in.
Cedar Roof Price Per Square Foot
In Lancaster, the average cedar roof price per square foot ranges between $21 and $25, which equals roughly $2,100 to $2,500 per square (a roofing “square” = 100 square feet). For most single-family homes, that puts the total cedar roof cost between $25,000 and $40,000, depending on roof complexity.
At JMK Roofing, we price our cedar roofing installations around $2,100 per square, which includes high-quality cedar materials and full installation. We also offer synthetic cedar alternatives—from brands like DaVinci and F-Wave—that provide a similar aesthetic with lower maintenance and a longer lifespan.
Factors That Affect Cedar Roof Cost in Lancaster PA
It’s helpful to know what’s influencing the price tag so you can make informed decisions. Let’s break down the key cost drivers.
Roof Design Complexity
The more hips, valleys, skylights, and dormers you have, the more labor and material are required. A simple gable roof will cost less than a complex multi-pitch design.
Material Type and Grade
Cedar comes in two primary grades—#1 Blue Label (clear, vertical grain, fewer knots) and #2 or “Select” (some knots, mixed grain). Blue Label is the premium option and lasts longer, but it’s more expensive upfront.
We always recommend starting with a higher-quality shake—it can save you money on repairs and replacements later.
Installation Expertise
Cedar roofing installation in Lancaster is more specialized than asphalt shingle roofing. It requires precise spacing, proper ventilation, and an understanding of how cedar behaves over time. Not every roofing contractor has the experience to do it right.
At JMK Roofing, we’ve installed dozens of cedar roofs over the years, and we stand behind our work with a 10-year workmanship warranty.
Cedar Shake Roofing Lancaster: What to Expect From the Process
If you decide to move forward with cedar, here’s how the process typically goes from first call to final cleanup.
Step 1: Estimate and Consultation
We’ll schedule an on-site visit to inspect your roof, take measurements, and talk through your options. We’ll also walk you through financing if you’re interested.
Step 2: Proposal and Material Selection
Once we know what you need, we’ll build a detailed proposal. This includes your cedar roof cost, timeline, materials, and warranty info. You’ll choose from natural or synthetic options and select the finish that works best for your home.
Step 3: Roofing Installation
We’ll schedule your installation during ideal weather conditions—typically between March and October here in Lancaster. Our crew will handle everything, from tear-off to cleanup.
Step 4: Final Walkthrough and Warranty
Once we wrap up, we’ll do a final walkthrough and provide documentation for your 10-year workmanship warranty, along with any manufacturer warranties that apply.
Maintenance: What You Need to Know
Regular Inspections
We recommend having your cedar roof inspected every 2-3 years. We look for signs of wear, moss, or damage from weather and branches.
Cleaning and Treatments
In our region, humidity can encourage moss growth. Light power washing (when done carefully) and applying a preservative treatment can extend the life of your cedar roof.
Repairs
We handle all types of cedar roof repairs—from replacing individual shakes to full section rebuilds. Staying on top of minor issues will help avoid costly fixes down the road.
Cedar vs. Synthetic Cedar: Which Is Better?
If you love the look of cedar but worry about the maintenance, synthetic cedar is a strong option. Brands like DaVinciand F-Wave offer composite shingles that look almost identical to natural wood, with lower upkeep and longer lifespans.
- Synthetic Cost: Around the same or slightly more per square than natural cedar
- Lifespan: 40–50 years
- Warranty: Often longer than natural products
- Maintenance: Minimal
We install both natural and synthetic cedar and can help you decide what makes the most sense for your home and budget.
Why Homeowners in Lancaster Choose JMK Roofing
We know you’re not just looking for a roofer—you’re looking for someone you can trust with your home. Here’s why homeowners choose us:
- Local Experience: We’ve been serving the Lancaster area since 2012
- Skilled Craftsmanship: Our team is trained and experienced in cedar roofing installation
- Clear Communication: From your first call to the final nail, we keep you in the loop
- Top Materials: We use the highest quality cedar shakes and synthetic alternatives available
- Financing Options: Flexible plans are available to help you invest in your home without the financial stress
And most importantly, we treat your roof like it’s our own. After all, Your Roof, Our Reputation isn’t just a tagline—it’s how we do business.
Ready to Learn More About Cedar Roofing Installation in Lancaster?
If you’re still wondering how much does a cedar roof cost or want to explore whether cedar shake roofing in Lancaster is right for your home, we’re here to help. Whether you’re replacing an old roof or building something brand new, we’ll guide you every step of the way.
Call us at (717) 940-4690 or email [email protected] to schedule your estimate. We’ll answer your questions, give you a clear proposal, and help you feel confident in your decision—no pressure, just honest help.
