Let’s be honest. Figuring out the real cost of new siding for your home can feel like trying to hit a moving target. You might search online for “how much does siding cost in Lancaster PA” and find wildly different answers. Maybe you’ve even spoken with a few siding contractors in Lancaster PA, only to end the conversation more confused than when you started.
At JMK Roofing, we get it. You’re not just spending money. You’re investing in your home’s protection, energy efficiency, and curb appeal. That’s why we’re cutting through the fluff to give you clear, practical insights into siding installation cost, with numbers you can actually use. Whether you’re eyeing fiber cement, LP SmartSide, or metal siding, we’ve got your back.
Let’s dig in.
Why You’re Probably Here
You’re dealing with worn or outdated siding or worse, moisture damage.
Maybe your current siding is cracked, warped, or fading. Maybe your energy bills are climbing, and you’ve read that new siding can help insulate your home better. Or perhaps you’re getting your place ready to sell and want to boost that all-important first impression.
Whatever your situation, the big question on your mind is likely: “How much does new siding cost in Lancaster PA?”
What Influences Siding Installation Cost?
You already know that every home is different. But here are the biggest factors that will determine your project’s bottom line.
1. Material Type
This is the main driver of siding cost and also where it’s easiest to get overwhelmed. For homeowners around Lancaster, we typically work with three high-performing siding materials:
- Fiber Cement (like Hardie Board)
- LP SmartSide (engineered wood)
- Metal Siding
We don’t offer vinyl siding, but we understand why people search for “vinyl siding prices.” Vinyl’s upfront price is appealing, but it often sacrifices longevity and resistance to damage. Our preferred materials last longer and provide better value over time, saving you maintenance and replacement costs down the road.
On average, you can expect the new siding cost for our top-tier materials to start around $800 per square (that’s 100 square feet). While vinyl siding prices may come in lower, the performance gap is hard to ignore.
2. House Size and Design
A single-story ranch will cost less to side than a two-story colonial with multiple gables and dormers. Complex architecture takes more time and more materials, plain and simple.
3. Removal of Old Siding
If your existing siding needs to come off, that adds labor and disposal fees to the bill. At JMK Roofing, we’re transparent about these costs and include them in your estimate so there are no surprises.
4. Custom Features
Want decorative trim? Vertical accents? A splash of color with metal siding on one elevation? Those add aesthetic punch and some added cost. But if boosting your home’s value is a goal, those touches can pay off in a big way.
Average Siding Cost in Lancaster, PA
Let’s talk numbers. For a standard-sized home (say, 2,000 square feet of exterior wall), your total siding installation cost will usually range between $15,000 and $20,000 for premium materials like fiber cement or engineered wood.
Here’s a breakdown by material:
| Siding Type | Average Cost per Square | Notes |
| Fiber Cement (Hardie) | $800 | Durable, fire-resistant, low maintenance |
| LP SmartSide | $800 | Lighter weight, smooth or textured finish |
| Metal Siding | Varies (higher) | Modern aesthetic, weather-resistant |
Again, if you’re Googling “vinyl siding prices,” you might find numbers closer to $400 per square. But that upfront saving could mean sacrificing durability and style and investing in a second replacement down the line.
How JMK Roofing Solves Your Siding Challenges
As homeowners ourselves, we know how frustrating it is to navigate inconsistent estimates, sketchy contractors, and radio silence after the first conversation. That’s why we’ve made it our mission to do things differently.
Clear, Upfront Pricing
We’ll give you a detailed, transparent estimate. No vague line items. No bait-and-switch. Just honest numbers based on real measurements and your unique preferences.
Premium Materials Only
We don’t cut corners. We use siding that’s proven to last, sourced from manufacturers we trust like Hardie, LP, and select metal panel brands.
Strong Workmanship Warranty
You’ll get a 10-year workmanship warranty from us on all siding installations. That’s our way of saying we stand behind every nail and panel.
Responsive, Local Team
We’re not some out-of-town company chasing insurance jobs. We live here. We’ve been serving this community since 2012. You can call, text, or email, and you’ll actually get a reply. Imagine that.
What to Expect During the Siding Process
Here’s a quick look at how our siding projects typically unfold.
Step 1: Consultation + Estimate
We’ll visit your home to evaluate its current condition, take measurements, and discuss your goals and style preferences. This visit is also when we’ll talk about budget and timeline.
Step 2: Material Selection
Whether you’re going for the clean lines of Hardie Board, the warmth of LP SmartSide, or an eye-catching metal accent, we’ll guide you through the choices to fit your home and budget.
Step 3: Tear-Off (if needed)
If old siding needs to go, we’ll handle the removal efficiently and responsibly, making sure to minimize mess and disruption.
Step 4: Installation
Our experienced crew gets to work, installing your new siding with precision and care. We follow manufacturer guidelines to protect your product warranty and ensure long-term performance.
Step 5: Cleanup + Final Walkthrough
We leave your property looking better than we found it, and we’ll walk the job with you to make sure you’re 100% satisfied.
The Hidden Value of Quality Siding
Let’s talk about the return on investment. New siding isn’t just about fresh curb appeal. It’s about protecting your home from moisture intrusion, improving insulation, and increasing resale value.
According to industry data, high-quality siding can recoup up to 80% of its cost when you sell. And if you’re staying put? Enjoy lower energy bills, less maintenance, and a home that makes you proud every time you pull into the driveway.
Let’s Talk About Your Home
We know you’ve got choices when it comes to siding contractors in Lancaster PA. But if you want a team that values communication, integrity, and quality craftsmanship, we’d be honored to earn your trust.
Whether you’re just curious or ready to start, reach out for a personalized estimate. We’re happy to walk you through your options, answer your questions, and help you feel confident in whatever decision you make.
Call us at (717) 940-4690 or email [email protected] to schedule your free siding consultation.
Because your home deserves better than vague pricing and unreliable workmanship.
Your Roof, Our Reputation. Now for siding too.
